MMO monetization practices
Players critique aggressive monetization in MMOs like Aion, Throne and Liberty, and Lost Ark, highlighting issues like pay-to-win, gatekeeping, and subscriptions that lock basic features like the auction house.
- Aion, described as 'free to play' for PvE, becomes pay-to-win ('p2w') in PvP, with a stamina system that prolongs gear acquisition, and a subscription cost in Brazil described as 'pretty high' for the region (81 Brazilian bucks a month, or 41 according to another member).
- Monetization models often lead to 'gatekeeping' in PvE content, where players are excluded for not being over-geared or having specific classes, as seen in Lost Ark, Aion 2, and Throne and Liberty.
- NCSoft, the publisher, is criticized for its monetization strategies, particularly locking essential features like the auction house behind a subscription, despite evidence of successful alternative models like Guild Wars 2's 'pay-for-content' with a free shop.
- The subscription model is also questioned for its effectiveness against bots and real-money trading (RMT), referencing World of Warcraft's long history with these issues despite having a subscription.


