feedback etiquette debate
A discussion unfolds about the etiquette of commenting on someone's creative work, particularly concerning whether certain comments could be seen as trolling or dismissive of effort.
- One member initially described a creative post as a 'shitpost' (1, 2), which another member found potentially offensive as it might dismiss the effort put into the work (5, 7, 8).
- The member who made the 'shitpost' comment clarified that they meant it as a meme to troll and be funny, not to imply lack of effort, citing the original poster's known trolling behavior (6, 10, 13).
- The debate intensified around the definition of 'shitpost' (15, 16) and whether comments, even if not meant to harass, should be kept to oneself to avoid hurting feelings (26, 28, 30).
- Elements like a PNG of people and a 'pls win' message in the original post were cited as reasons why it might be perceived as a meme (19, 23, 24).


