Sonic Mania versus Sonic Superstars
Players favor Sonic Mania over Sonic Superstars, criticizing Superstars for underutilizing Trip, tedious boss fights, and lackluster gameplay.
- Sonic Mania and Sonic Generations are cited as favorite franchise entries, with Mania viewed as the pinnacle 2D Sonic game
- Sonic Superstars is viewed unfavorably or mediocre compared to Mania and its Encore mode
- The Death Egg Robot boss fight in Superstars is criticized as a waste of time
- Players express disappointment that the character Trip was introduced in Superstars but only featured in one game


