rewarding defense in shard war
Players and developers debate Shard War scoring, focusing on whether rewarding defense or participation prevents players from emptying keeps.
- Requiring a minimum attack threshold risks players doing last-minute attacks outside walls, while contribution-weighted rewards disadvantage casual participants
- Players argue defending must be rewarded win or lose, otherwise people will refuse to engage and leave keeps empty
- Rewarding the losing side risks incentivizing players to put keeps outside walls to get rewards for zero effort
- Defending feels unrewarding because attackers inevitably win, meaning time spent defending takes away from earning attack points
- The kill board currently serves as the main incentive for losing shards to participate and provide PvP targets


