drake maye superstar status debate
Members debate whether Drake Maye deserves superstar status, criticizing his tight-window throwing and questioning media hype after an MVP runner-up season.
- One member argues Maye only completes wide-open throws and struggles significantly with tight-window passes
- Media and Patriots fans heavily hyped Maye as a franchise-altering superstar after he finished as the MVP runner-up behind Stafford by one vote
- Another member questions whether a single strong season qualifies any quarterback as a true superstar across the league
- Comparisons were drawn to pre-draft evaluations where commentators ranked Maye above Caleb Williams as the class's top quarterback


